How to balance results and people as a leader
Nov 01, 2026"The numbers look good, so why does my team look like they hate me?"
I hear some version of that from leaders a lot. They're pushing hard because that's the job. The targets are getting hit. And the team is getting quieter and more tired.
A lot of us were taught that we have to pick one. Push for results, or look after your people. If you've ever wondered how to balance results and people as a leader, here's where I've landed after years of leading teams and coaching leaders: I don't think that choice is real.
Last week I wrote about the strength that might be covering your gap. This week is about what happens when the numbers become the whole conversation.
Why your head takes over under pressure
The pressure comes from above. The board wants the number. Your boss wants the number. Or you've promised yourself the number.
So you walk into the Monday meeting and it's all targets. What's behind, and what has to happen by Friday. And that works for a while, until it doesn't.
When you're under pressure, your head takes over. It's logical and it's great at getting a result. That's a real strength.
The trouble is, it stops noticing the people who are delivering the result.
The cost that doesn't show on the dashboard
Here's what it looks like from the other side of the table, from your team's perspective.
Your best person stops putting their hand up and saying, "Yes, I'll do that." The team still delivers, but they're running on fumes.
None of that shows up on the dashboard until the day someone hands in their notice. And at this time of year, that's the last thing any of us can afford.
When we look back, the signs were usually there all along. We missed them because we got stuck in the numbers. We went transactional.
Can you be a supportive manager and still get results?
So is it really results or people?
One large survey, reported by the World Economic Forum, asked over 60,000 employees what made a leader great in their eyes. The leaders who focused on results and people together were rated great 72% of the time. Focusing on just one of them didn't reliably get them there.
That's what I call Head and Heart Integration. It's the fifth pillar of my Exceptional Leader Framework. Our head sets the standard, and our heart keeps our people with us while we get there.
What leading with heart actually looks like
This is the part that gets misunderstood a lot.
Leading with heart doesn't mean lowering the bar on expectations. It means you still ask for the number, and you also notice the person you're asking.
You can say, "This has to be done by Friday." And you can also say, "I can see you've been carrying a lot. What would help you?"
Both of those sentences can live in the same conversation. That's the skill.
Transactional or relational? The good cop, bad cop trap
I see leaders getting stuck here all the time. It's really about the balance between transactional and relational, and it's one of the most common topics to come up in my 1:1 coaching. A lot of us get uncomfortable setting expectations and checking in at the same time.
When we get caught in our head, we come across as transactional and only caring about the bottom line. We can sound a bit dismissive, too task focused and a bit too instructional.
When we're too much in our heart space, we tend to stretch the boundaries. We rescue people and get caught up in their issues, carrying them as our own.
Sometimes we even split the job with another leader and play good cop, bad cop. One clarifies the expectations and the other provides the support, the touchy feely stuff.
That's not how we get the best from our team. There are no good cops and bad cops in leadership.
In my experience, the leaders with the strongest teams are the ones who've worked on getting this balance right themselves. Their people feel safe and supported, and they start solving problems and setting targets for themselves. And those leaders are a lot less tired at the end of the week.
How to hit targets without burning out your team
Here's a question to sit with. When the pressure's on, which one do you reach for first? Your head or your heart?
Then try one thing this week.
In your next conversation about targets, before you get to the numbers, ask one question about how the person is going with their load. Listen to the whole answer before you move on.
Then hold the standard. Both, in the same conversation.
Finish the year without running on empty
If this has landed, and you're feeling stretched heading into the end of the year, I'm running a live session on Zoom on Thursday 19 November, 12pm to 1pm AEDT. It's called Finish the Year Without Running on Empty, and we'll look at where your energy is really going and how to get your head and your heart working together for the last few weeks of the year.
Prefer to watch or listen? Watch the video or listen to the podcast.
When the pressure's on, do you lean on your head or your heart? Tell me in the comments.
Check out my On Line Course!
Take your Leadership skills to a whole new level, whether you are a seasoned professional or new to leadership.
Be Exceptional
The on Line Course that shares the secrets to how to show up as a Leader without the burnout and overwhelm.
